objectives
members
enquires
annual report
press release
articles
articles
political objectives
 

23 August 2011

 

BRANCH NETWORK REDUCTION : 2011 REPORT

   
 
Branches Closed (Net) Since 1-1-90
Since 1-1-01
(10 years)
All banks (includes converted building societies) 7555 (-44%) 1889 (-16%)
Traditional banks 5891*(-43%) 1220*(-14%)
 

At 31-12-2010 only 9737 retail bank branches remained, down 181. The traditional Big 4 banks (Big 3 in Scotland) operate the only bank branches in 97% of rural and suburban communities which are dependent on only one bank.

 
Communities    
Lost all banks
1200  
With only 1 bank 900  
With 2 banks 450  
With 3 or more banks 1250  
 
European Comparisons (branches per million inhabitants)
UK
  160 (190 with Building Societies)
France 420  
Italy 560  
Germany

470

 
Spain 940  

Also there is a better geographical spread in the other countries, which retain regionally and locally owned banks, but generally make modest charges for operating personal as well as business accounts.

 
Big 5 Net Closures* Since 1-1-90 Since 1-1-01 Leaving at 31-12-10
LTSB (E & W) 1858   413     1600
NatWest 1448   94  

 

1549
Barclays 1081   163     1658
HSBC 731   357     1311
Santander 471   111     1175
 
 

From a low in 2007, something has changed and net branch closures by the traditional Big 4, at 183 in 2010, are again rising significantly with an emphasis on urban and rural communities down to their last one or two banks. Cuts in opening days/hours, often a precursor to closure, have also been a feature.

With higher capital costs and retail profits under pressure, branch closures in vulnerable communities are continuing in 2011 at a similar rate with no sign of a halt.

Neutral shared branching offers a cost effective way to sustain a branch presence in vulnerable communities, and elsewhere to significantly reduce operating costs, but to date the industry and governments have consistently failed to recognise the opportunities it affords.

The new player, Santander, is town centre focused and its network contains multiple overlaps crying out for rationalisations. This profile will not change materially when the RBS network in England & Wales (311) is taken over in 2012. New entrants to retail banking will not fill the closure voids in vulnerable communities.

 

Sources: CCBS Research, BBA Annual Abstract 2011, European Banking Federation 2011